All Blacks' defensive collapse raises serious questions over Dave Rennie's coaching staff
Henry Lee in London • November 23rd, 2026 7:44 am

Dave Rennie | Photo: Matt Impey/Photosport
Oh, how quickly the tables turn.
Just as All Blacks fans thought it couldn’t get much worse than losing to Wales for the first time in 73 years, Dave Rennie’s now side holds another unwanted record.
Sunday's horrifying 25-point defeat to England at Twickenham has put even more on the All Blacks.
It was the All Blacks’ biggest loss to a Northern Hemisphere side ever, and quite frankly, the visitors were lucky the points differential wasn’t greater.
From minute one, the All Blacks never looked like they were in the contest.
The defence was worryingly open at times and, when it wasn’t, the All Blacks were static and caught picking daisies as England’s ball carriers crashed over the gainline at ease.
Watto labels Dave Rennie a 'milestone coach' after England loss | The Rugby Run
What was the defensive strategy?
Jordie Barrett, the world’s premier second-five, can only do so much. If only the other 14 players on the field played with his heart and intensity.
Rennie went out to bat for Chiefs midfielder Anton Lienert-Brown midweek in London, and while the veteran wasn’t the worst at Twickenham, it was hardly encouraging.
On one occasion, Lienert-Brown was sucked in by the sweeping English attack and Cadan Murley couldn’t believe his eyes as he toed ahead to Will Joseph.
All Blacks captain Codie Taylor often steamed out of line to try put a shot on, disrupt, and possibly stop the ball carrier going forward, yet it was obvious he was lost in no-man's land and had little chance of halting the England attack.

Dejected New Zealand players at full time | Photo: Matt Impey/Photosport
Ben Earl, who contributed a mammoth 32 carries for Steve Borthwick’s side, couldn’t believe his eyes when he looked up to see Cameron Roigard alone in front of him. Damian McKenzie tried to help, but it was too late.
It all comes back to the systems and structures. Or are the players making rash decisions?
While it may be a mixture of both, the buck stops with the head coach and the assistants in charge of specific portfolios.
The All Blacks have often looked disconnected in 2026; is it due to the changing nature of the lineup, the game plan being handed to them by the coaches, or that international teams have identified specific areas they can target against the All Blacks?
Is Dave Rennie one of the worst All Black coaches?! | Scotty & Izzy
Something must change.
John Plumtree and Brad Mooar were sacked after the Ireland series defeat in 2022.
And given the precedent New Zealand Rugby set after last year’s capitulation against England under Scott Robertson, which was clearly more painful than this year’s brutal display, Rennie’s range of assistants are guaranteed to be in the limelight.
Another concerning issue is the lineout.
Under Bryn Evans in 2025, the lineout was one of their strengths. The lineout moves, most memorably Cameron Roigard’s try in Wellington against France, were a speciality.
Yes, Wallace Sititi crossed from a lineout move against Scotland, and Cortez Ratima against Wales in recent times, but the overall trajectory of the lineout is worrying.
England’s Maro Itoje is a classy lineout operator, but it’s not the first time they have had issues under Rennie.
Neil Barnes’ coaching portfolio is senior assistant coach, with a huge focus on lineout, and he must be held accountable moving forward.
All Blacks assistant coach Neil Barnes | Photo: Chris Symes/Photosport
There’s more than enough international experience in the second row; Fabian Holland and Scott Barrett have formed a strong combination, with Josh Lord, Sam Darry, and Jamie Hannah backing them up.
Scott Barrett has been a lineout caller for some of his career; Fabian Holland no doubt has the skillset to do so, too.
You add Taylor’s 116 Test matches, Tupou Vaa’i’s growing stature at lineout time, and there are zero excuses as to why the lineout is not functioning at above 90 per cent.
It may be the cattle, it may be the coaching, but whatever the underlying problems are, Rennie and his staff must find solutions before it's too late.
Mark Watson lets his feeling be known after the All Blacks loss to Wales | The Rugby Run

